Aladdin’s Corner: How do you measure a Feeling?

There was a question about how much to adjust for a slab home in an investor FB group.

Headline: Appraiser answer = ~ 4%. 
Sub headline: how do you measure a feeling?

The answer really depends so many variables but here is where that one specific ~4% answer came from.

I appraise Real Estate in the Greater Boston Area. After the ’09 crash I used the free time (no work) and learned regression analyses. I then used that to determine values of various characteristics in homes.

I downloaded 10 years of single family sales in Newton (6,000 sales +/-). I move on to Cambridge Condos and also in Natick and Framingham I studied Campanella slab ranch homes with no basement on level lots.

This Metro West real estate market was a great find because, unlike most of the Greater Boston Real Estate Market, this market has so many sales of “the same home” again and again with minor differences.

That makes it easier to figure out verifiable market values for various characteristics I was studying (bedrooms, bathrooms, sq.ft., patios, garages, baths etc.).

After scrubbing the data I compared slab ranches which are all on level lots, to basement ranches also on level lots. The basement ranches have the typical tiny awning windows, not embankment lots, and all their basement were unfinished . I just wanted to isolate one characteristic, the presence of a basement.

After removing the outliers, I discovered that the presence of a basement added from 2%-4%.

Appraisers are all at the mercy of the market consisting of whatever closed sales have occured. In an appraisal I will strive to use only slab homes when appraising a slab home.

I will go back 2 years looking for data to figure out the value. I may not use an old sale but will let it shape my opinion then I look for recent sales in that price range to support my value in the appraisal report.

I will also look at cancelations and expired listings which give me a potential value ceiling.

When I must mix slab and basement sales in the same appraisal I almost always adjust 4% for the slab. Of course there is more adjusting to compensate for a home has a finished owned/or embankment basement, but I would almost never include a walkout finished basement home to slab home.

The method I used was regression analysis in excel but there is software out there that does the work for you. I have no affiliation with any of them but we are about to play with Redstone which extracts MLS data for you then provide a set of regression tools. There are others out there as well.

Appraisal is a blend of art and science. These measurable percentages are “the science” of valuation. “The art” is in recognizing that feelings matter. That on any given weekend there may be a glut or dearth of homes competing for the same buyers (comps) and that variable will amplify or diminish the percentages I use.

Every day buyers shopping for homes are facing an ever-changing menu, in an imperfect market, and throw emotion into the soup and people buy based on a feeling. How do you measure that?

There is probably no exact answer to any value question and yet appraisers must state an opinion of value backed up by verified market data.

We have 3 approaches to value in real estate appraisal.
The income approach (investors!)
The cost approach (land + construction – depreciation)
The sales comparison approach to value (adjusted and weighted sales prices of comparable homes).

Some appraisals are easy and the value obvious. Sometimes I end up close to minimum wage.

In the end I think that in challenging cases what appraisers really do is best described as a 4th approach to value, the Scientific Wild Assed Guess Approach (S.W.A.G ).

It is a feeling based on the total mental immersion into the market for the home. It is hard to teach and not quickly attainable, but I’ve competed over 4,000 appraisals worth over 2 billion dollars and I got it somewhere along the way.

In my opinion it may be the most important and hardest part of valuation to learn.


Best of luck!

Adam Wiener


If you liked this article and want more, please leave a comment below.

You may also see similar content on our FB page.

To follow us, click HERE and hit LIKE.

Aladdin’s Corner: The 7 Most Common Issues and Errors with Real Estate Appraisals

The Art of Deciphering Appraisal Reports I conduct appraisal review assignments for attorneys, accountants, banks, lenders, appraisal management companies and other clients as part of my appraisal practice. There are two types of real estate appraisal reports which I review; FNMA or lender reports and market value or non-lender reports.  For this article I will […]

Aladdin’s Corner: What to know when getting an Appraisal during a Divorce

Property Valuation for Divorce and Appraisals In a divorce, the marital home is oftentimes sold, and any profits are split between the parties. Alternatively, if financially possible, one of the parties may buy out the other.  The question of “who keeps the house?” depends far more on the house value than it does on who […]

How to Verify the Home You Want to List

5 Steps Appraisers use in a Sales Comparison (How to Calculate the List Price of a Home)   This is part 1a of 6 – How to Verify the home You Want to List (Please note:  I realized the importance of adding step 1a after writing the first blog in the series. Verifying exactly what […]

5 Steps Appraisers us in the Sales Comparison- Part 1 of 6

Part 1 of 6 – Appraisal Techniques for Real estate Brokers Welcome to the first of a six -part blog series which shows how residential appraisers value real estate using comparable sales.  I will take the methods we use and break them down into simple terms using real life examples.   Who should be reading […]

HOMESTEAD- Protect your Home

Friends of mine recently refinanced their house and the attorney pointed out that there was a change in Mass law to protect homeowners.  It raised the amount that you can protect significantly, but you must file with the county to get the protection.  The link below explains the law. Under the amended Homestead Act, […]

Prices per Square Foot, the Truth for Home Buyers

A real estate appraiser’s perspective:  Buying a house based on the price per square foot is like paying for a car based on its miles per gallon; and yet to this day I see buyers, sellers, mortgage and real estate professionals discussing and using square foot price as a method for comparing homes to try […]

PMI Removal Appraisals

Have you given any thought to exactly what makes up your monthly mortgage payment?  If you purchased your home with less than 20% down payment, you are paying private mortgage insurance (PMI). PMI is an insurance you agreed to pay to compensate for the higher risk the lender took on your purchase.  With favorable market […]

How to Win a Property Tax Appeal

If you are a Massachusetts property owner and believe you are paying more than your fair share of property taxes you only have a limited amount of time to appeal, depending on your city or town.  Typically the appeal deadline is prior to the date of the first annual payment, although you still have to […]

Bankruptcy and Appraisals, What You Need to Know

Local attorneys report that most trustees overseeing chapter 7 and 13 bankruptcies will accept a simple broker’s opinion of value (BPO) or even a Zestimate. This means chances are you will not be required to get an actual real estate appraisal which helps keep your overall costs down and expedite the process; however, you should […]

What is the Actual Square Footage of My House?

Would you believe most people don’t really know how many square feet of living area are in the home they own, are about to list, buy or sell.  Our experience with Greater Boston real estate appraisals continues to prove this truth. ANSI Z-765 (the American National Standard Institute publication) is the go-to method for calculating square […]